I did a colony scan on him myself and it showed something like 2800E. It was a big deal at the time, which is why I remember. Accuracy on colony scan isnt perfect but it beats yours I think. I don't know if BAD still plays at all.
And yes, he couldnt relocate. His alliance was dead and only he survived. No ops, no allies. I dont remember exactly how many missiles he ioned but it was somewhere around 10.